Do forum signatures violate Google Webmaster TOS?

Beverly Level X³

June 10, 2013, 10:32 pm

11

Write the reason you're deleting this FAQ

Do forum signatures violate Google Webmaster TOS?

According to Google Webmaster TOS, an optimized forum signature could be an unnatural links that violates their guidelines.

Forum comments with optimized links in the post or signature, for example:
Thanks, that’s great info!
- Paul
paul’s pizza san diego pizza best pizza san diego

http://support.google.com/webmaste...amp;answer=66356

However, forum signatures could still be relevant for backlinking and SEO purposes if presented properly. What are some ways a forum signature could be made so it is not considered an 'artificial link' by Google?

Comments

Please login or sign up to leave a comment

Join

Keith

For instance, let's say you have a pizza delivery service. Then you might only post on forum pages that talk about pizza or pizza delivery. That way, your forum signature (pizza delivery) does not seem out of place as it is related to the content on that page and linking to pages about pizza. You could apply that idea to SEO or house decorating or gardening or any subject.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Caitlin

Start discussions that are specific to your niche. So if you are into internet marketing, you would start discussions about SEO, marketing, etc. Then your forum signature would be seen in context as it would be about internet marketing or other marketing related keywords.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

WilderRose

Don't just use keywords for your signature line. Take time to add a full description that is not hyperlinked in the forum signature. That will make your forum signature look more legitimate to site admin and also to search engines as the links are in context of other related content.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Annie Rose

Don't just use keywords for your signature line. Take time to add a full description that is not hyperlinked in the forum signature. That will make your forum signature look more legitimate to site admin and also to search engines as the links are in context of other related content.

But you are often limited on length of signature line. Would you put your link at the start of this 'paragraph' of info in your signature line or would you put it in the middle?

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Beverly

Start discussions that are specific to your niche. So if you are into internet marketing, you would start discussions about SEO, marketing, etc. Then your forum signature would be seen in context as it would be about internet marketing or other marketing related keywords.

But don't you still see signature links on forums that have nothing to do with the content on that forum or page? For instance, I'm always visiting SEO forums and seeing signature links for apartments in Dubai. Is this normal? Also doesn't that look suspicious to Google, especially when the forum has nothing to do with apartments or Dubai?

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

shek

Do you really think the answers on google community are standardized ? Most of the answers on that site are based on observations. And observations might not reveal actual fact, especially when google is changing/optimizing there algo almost every month !

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

MikeQ

Forum signature should be relevant and if you are participating in some quality forums then you would get benefit, you would get benefit from SEO as well as traffics.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Beverly

Do you really think the answers on google community are standardized ? Most of the answers on that site are based on observations. And observations might not reveal actual fact, especially when google is changing/optimizing there algo almost every month !

But it's from Google's official help pages, where they talk about types of Link Schemes. Hopefully, there are still some types of forum signatures which are not considered spammy backlinks as backlinking from forums is one of the easiest ways to do SEO.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

kailashseo368

Forum signatures are a brilliant source of targeted traffic and that's what I use it for. The problem is (and I see this across many forums) people over-optimize their signatures and that's a violation of Google's ToS. Signatures like "Foreclosure Miami", "Houston Real Estate" etc. will incur the unnatural links penalty.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Tommy Matalino

Using 3 anchor texts tor a single link seems to be really too much and can be considered as spamming. Besides, I don't think you'll get 3x the link juice or traffic when doing that...

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Beverly

Forum signatures are a brilliant source of targeted traffic and that's what I use it for. The problem is (and I see this across many forums) people over-optimize their signatures and that's a violation of Google's ToS. Signatures like "Foreclosure Miami", "Houston Real Estate" etc. will incur the unnatural links penalty.

This type of anchor text only signature line looks very unnatural as it's usually surrounded by no other text. Most times when backlinking, I will add the maximum amount of text (not linked) as a description of the site being backlinked to. The description doesn't contain keywords but sometimes has related words that help describe the site more accurately such as content, theme, etc.

13 years ago

Are you sure you want to delete this post?

Process Time: 0.087048053741455

Possible Duplicate queries found!

Match	Count	SQL	Script
SELECT * FROM members_ledger WHERE ip = ? AND added>=unix_timestamp(NOW())-86400	1	SELECT querystring, added FROM members_ledger WHERE ip = ? AND added>=unix_timestamp(NOW())-86400	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/includes/security.php 398 fetchMemberLedger() include_once()
SELECT * FROM `questions` as q JOIN categories_faq as c ON q.catid=c.CATID WHERE (q.status=1 OR (q.status=2 AND userid='') ) AND q.quesid='14911'	1	SELECT q.*, c.seo as CatSEO, c.name as CatName, c.parentid FROM `questions` as q JOIN categories_faq as c ON q.catid=c.CATID WHERE (q.status=1 OR (q.status=2 AND userid='') ) AND q.quesid='14911'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/viewfaq.php 496 () ()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='147'	1	SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='147'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/includes/member.php 445 GetAllUserDetails() ()
SELECT * FROM categories_faq WHERE CATID='30'	1	SELECT CATID, seo, name, metatitle, h2header, metakeywords, metadescription, metaheader, parentid, image_name FROM categories_faq WHERE CATID='30'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() GetCategorySeoFromType()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID=147	1	SELECT googleplus_profile FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID=147	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 16914 GetGooglePlusProfileFromId() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faq as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=14911 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faq as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=14911 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM answers a, seoclerks.members b WHERE a.quesid='14911' AND a.userid=b.USERID and b.status='1' AND a.status=1 ORDER BY a.combined_votes DESC, a.date_answered asc	1	SELECT a.answer, a.USERID, a.upvotes, a.downvotes, a.ansid, a.parentid, a.combined_votes, a.date_answered, b.username, b.userlevel, b.profilepicture FROM answers a, seoclerks.members b WHERE a.quesid='14911' AND a.userid=b.USERID and b.status='1' AND a.status=1 ORDER BY a.combined_votes DESC, a.date_answered asc	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/viewfaq.php 1245 () ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78787 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78787 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78788 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78788 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78789 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78789 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78790 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78790 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78791 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78791 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78792 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78792 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78793 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78793 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78794 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78794 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78795 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78795 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78796 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78796 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
SELECT * FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78797 LIMIT 5	1	SELECT m.username FROM ratings_faqanswers as r, seoclerks.members as m WHERE r.USERID=m.USERID AND r.upvote=1 AND r.PID=78797 LIMIT 5	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 17159 GetVoters() ()
UPDATE questions SET total_views = total_views + 1 WHERE quesid='14911'	1	UPDATE questions SET total_views = total_views + 1 WHERE quesid='14911'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/include/functions/main.php 1765 update_Faqviewcount() ()
SELECT * FROM questions WHERE quesid!='14911' AND status='1' AND (question like '%Do forum signatures violate Google Webmaster TOS?%' OR question like '%forum%' OR question like '%signatures%' OR question like '%violate%' OR question like '%Google%' OR question like '%Webmaster%' OR question like '%TOS?%') -- ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT 15	1	SELECT quesid, question, seo, userid FROM questions WHERE quesid!='14911' AND status='1' AND (question like '%Do forum signatures violate Google Webmaster TOS?%' OR question like '%forum%' OR question like '%signatures%' OR question like '%violate%' OR question like '%Google%' OR question like '%Webmaster%' OR question like '%TOS?%') -- ORDER BY RAND() LIMIT 15	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() ()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='672' limit 1	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='672' limit 1	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_get_member_profilepicture()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='43' limit 1	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='43' limit 1	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_get_member_profilepicture()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='9' limit 1	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='9' limit 1	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_get_member_profilepicture()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='498' limit 1	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='498' limit 1	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_get_member_profilepicture()
SELECT * FROM members_ledger WHERE script='/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/viewfaq.php' AND querystring LIKE '%id=14911%' AND added>=UNIX_TIMESTAMP(NOW())-1200 GROUP BY USERID	1	SELECT USERID, username FROM members_ledger WHERE script='/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/viewfaq.php' AND querystring LIKE '%id=14911%' AND added>=UNIX_TIMESTAMP(NOW())-1200 GROUP BY USERID	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() ()
SELECT * FROM categories	1	SELECT * FROM categories	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() parseRedundantQueriesCache()
select * from categories_software order by name asc	1	select * from categories_software order by name asc	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_GetSoftwareCategories()
select * from categories_wanttobuy order by name asc	1	select * from categories_wanttobuy order by name asc	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_get_wantcategories()
select * from categories_wanttotrade order by name asc	1	select * from categories_wanttotrade order by name asc	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_get_tradecategories()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='20907.jpg'	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='20907.jpg'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() getUserProfileImage()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='21613.jpg'	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='21613.jpg'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() getUserProfileImage()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='20916.jpg'	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='20916.jpg'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() getUserProfileImage()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='147.jpg'	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='147.jpg'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() getUserProfileImage()
SELECT * FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='43.jpg'	1	SELECT profilepicture FROM seoclerks.members WHERE USERID='43.jpg'	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() getUserProfileImage()
select * from categories_faq order by name asc	1	select * from categories_faq order by name asc	/opt/clerks-staging/docroot/libraries/adodb5/adodb.inc.php 1899 CacheExecute() insert_GetFaqCategories()

Invalid SQL

count(*)	sql1	error_msg

Expensive SQL

Tuning the following SQL could reduce the server load substantially

Load

Count

SQL

Max

Min

Suspicious SQL

The following SQL have high average execution times

Avg Time

Count

SQL

Max

Min